Rough Hewn and Hardcore History: Instrument (1998)

Jem Cohen's alt-documentary Instrument (1999) on the post-punk band Fugazi, screened at Chicago's most alt-art house theater, Chicago Filmmakers on March 15 to a sizable crowd—at least considering what the theater normally draws in on any given Saturday night on the far-North side of Chicago. Only one other time have I seen a crowd outnumber Instrument's; about a year ago the CF curators picked up the never-seen Super-8 home movie reels of President Richard Nixon and his staff from the Library of Congress to, I believe, a sold out crowd of...50? And even that could be an exaggerated figure.
As for the venue itself, Chicago Filmmakers can't quite be classified as a theater. With its neat rows of stacking chairs lined before a projection screen not much larger than 8-feet square, Chicago Filmmakers more closely resembles a ramshackle screening room, which I should insert only adds to its earnest charm. There are no snacks or concessions, and I have no clue where the restroom might be. But you don't go to Chicago Filmmakers to be comfortable. In a way, its reminiscent of a classroom screening room; you believe you are watching something worth paying serious attention to for broader reasons than mere entertainment. I'll fess up, I brought my notebook to last December's Len Lye screening.
Instrument began with a bang. Fervent visions of Ian MacKaye and his Fugazi bandmates filled the screen and funk-infused punk beats rattled the eardrum. This was optimistic. It was a lot of unrestrained visual and aural energy, brought to life with Super-8, 16mm and video footage, and various clips from concerts and jam sessions from ten years of the band's history. For someone like myself who doesn't know the D.C. based band, it is a kind introduction to Fugazi's music, philosophy and politics. They are the least likely in the music industry to sell out to "the man"; MacKaye co-created his own independent record label, Dischord Records, to avoid just that. The band manages themselves and records in the basement of an anonymous suburban home. With no pretension of the typical rock lifestyle, it's not Entertainment Tonight they seek for their band's promotion; Ian MacKaye sits down for an 8th grade class's rip on a daytime talk show interview (the pubescent hostess awkwardly asks on the grainy home movie tape, "I understand you've brought a clip, is that correct?") Yet with only underground or grassroots promotion, solely playing all-ages shows in places like school gyms or local homes, the class interview is a strange but wise regional promotion campaign, and as the film proves in time, a rather smart way to turn youth on to their pacifist and liberal political message.
The film runs at 115 minutes, but probably could have been shaved down to the 90-minute range (or less), if only to halt the repetition of images and tropes we've already seen. The most pronounced of those was a sequence of the faces of fans in line before the show: close-ups of disaffected youth, straight-faced and wearing grungy t-shirts and over-sized flannels, it had the odd likeness of monotonously flipping through a stranger's old yearbook. Though it does, nonetheless, serve as a handy sequel to 2006's American Hardcore that much of the time centers on Ian MacKaye's earlier years with Black Flag.


